How Arrivo Got Colorado to Back a Wild-Eyed Highway Scheme

The proposals that Brogan BamBrogan and Andrew Liu showed Shailen Bhatt promised a fanciful world: highways moving ten times more vehicles than they do now. Shipments zipping throughout the Denver area at 200 miles per hour. People getting from their homes to the airport gate in minutes. A new mode of transportation, moving people in numbers and speed far beyond what any metro system in the world accomplishes today. “The end of traffic,” they called it.

This was August 2017, when BamBrogan and Liu, cofounders of futuristic transportation company Arrivo, pitched Bhatt, then the executive director of the Colorado Department of Transportation, on their ambitious vision. They hoped to enter a partnership with the governing body on their “inspired by the Hyperloop concept.”

Arrivo’s pitch promised its technology would propel both specifically designed pods and people’s personal cars on sleds at hundreds of miles an hour, running along the medians of existing highways. Based on “linear-electric motors and magnetic levitation,” it would cost about the same to use as public transit or a toll road.

Bhatt says he was less captivated by their vision than their goal of building a proof-of-concept test track in Colorado, which would mean jobs for the state. In a follow-up letter sent to the Arrivo cofounders, which WIRED obtained along with Arrivo’s pitch materials and other documents through a public records request, he said he shared an Arrivo document with then-governor’s John Hickenlooper’s office. He assured BamBrogan and Liu that their interest in partnering with Colorado “has interest at the highest level.”

On November 14, the Colorado DOT, Arrivo, and the E-470 Public Highway Authority announced a partnership to build a test track along E-470, the toll interstate that runs through the western Denver suburbs and connects to Denver International Airport. They would hire up to 200 employees and conduct feasibility studies in exchange for $267,000 in performance-based incentives from the Colorado Office of Economic Development. Along with renderings of the system, Arrivo released a video of Bhatt and BamBrogan admiring classic cars and talking about transportation technology. In a press release announcing the deal, BamBrogan boasted, “Arrivo will end traffic and futureproof regional mobility.”

It didn’t quite work out that way. At the end of 2018, Arrivo shut down due to a lack of funding. Construction on the test track, originally slated to begin in the first quarter of 2018, never broke ground. Arrivo never completed its feasibility study. There is no evidence the company ever completed a proof of concept at any scale. BamBrogan did not respond to an interview request, and attempts to reach Liu were unsuccessful.

The speedy demise of Arrivo and its promised transportation system makes one wonder what CDOT saw in a company without any clear evidence it could deliver on outrageous promises. And it raises the larger questions of how much credibility future-focused mobility companies get by partnering with governments—even if their ideas amount to little more than glossy marketing brochures—and what those governments hope to gain in the process.

Indeed, Arrivo’s pitch to CDOT included claims that Yonah Freemark, a PhD candidate in urban studies at MIT and founder of the influential website The Transport Politic, calls “very unrealistic.” In one presentation, proposing a connection to the Denver airport, Arrivo promised its “Super Metro” people-mover, which could fit 20 or 30 passengers, would transport 72,000 to 108,000 people per hour. That’s three to four times the peak capacity of New York’s L subway train, one of the busiest in the system.

Arrivo’s pitch promised its technology would propel both specifically designed pods and people’s personal cars on sleds at hundreds of miles an hour, running along the medians of existing highways.

Arrivo

In a press release announcing Arrivo’s deal with Colorado, Brogan BamBrogan boasted, “Arrivo will end traffic and futureproof regional mobility.”

Arrivo

Meanwhile, Denver already has a good airport connector. In his book Trains, Buses, People, transportation expert Christof Spieler named the A line one of the best commuter rail lines in the country, noting it is the only such system in the country that runs every 15 minutes, seven days a week. (Spieler is, though, critical of Denver’s transit network in general.)

“We weren’t necessarily invested in the transformative piece of their technology,” says CDOT spokesperson Amy Ford. Rather, the agency wanted to investigate what the governance structure could look like should the technology come to fruition, she says. CDOT and Arrivo paid for their own studies with the consultant firm Aecom, Arrivo cofounder Liu’s previous employer. Ford says CDOT spent $250,000 on this study, which will cover not just Arrivo but other potential hyperloop and future mobility technologies. Ford described the expense as worthwhile regardless of Arrivo’s existence, and as a tiny portion of the department’s $1.4 billion annual budget. “If this was a 100-step process, we were at step, like, three,” Ford says.

Although Bhatt no longer works for CDOT, he says it will take big ideas to solve Colorado’s congestion challenges. Ten years ago, he wouldn’t have predicted app-based car services would transform urban transportation. Two years ago, he wouldn’t have guessed e-scooters would flood urban areas. Instead of trying to predict what will or won’t work, Bhatt says his role as a government official was to ask, “How do we make sure we are creating an environment where companies feel like they can come and do business?”

The Arrivo partnership fit into CDOT’s RoadX program, which encourages public-private partnerships to address serious congestion and a booming population. It’s all about big ideas. “We've been flying to the moon since the 1960s,” the RoadX web site beckons, “the time has come for transportation on this planet to make a giant leap.”

RoadX is perhaps the most coordinated effort by any state to court futuristic transportation companies, but it’s part of a larger trend. Elon Musk’s Boring Company has engaged, to varying degrees, with Chicago to build a tunnel from The Loop to O’Hare Airport (although that project is in serious jeopardy due to shifting political winds), two tunnels in LA (one of which was cancelled), and a Washington, D.C. to Baltimore connector. Virgin Hyperloop One, BamBrogan’s former employer, named CDOT among the 10 winners of a “Global Challenge” to propose feasible routes in welcoming places.

But for more traditional transportation experts, this shoot-for-the-moon mindset is indicative of this country’s mobility issues: While they like the idea of maglev trains and supersonic tubes, American cities often fail to get the basics of transportation planning right, like running reliable bus and rail service.

“Americans are constantly hoping for what's next, dreaming of some great new invention that will save them from whatever ills they currently experience,” says Freemark. “It's not surprising that the Arrivo videos are filled with scenes of people's daily lives—work, soccer, the beach—because it's meant to simply be placed on top of whatever we already have, yet somehow instantly make everything better. In that way, it's no surprise at all that political officials would find it appealing.”

One of the very reasons governments may find these futuristic options so attractive is they don’t yet know precisely how they will work, so they can fit any vision desirable. They’re essentially a blank slate, on which every improvement can be imagined and all downsides or skepticism assumed away. And who doesn’t want to be at the vanguard of innovation?

Arrivo’s flop hasn’t stopped Colorado from pursuing a shiny future. RoadX is moving ahead with its partnership with Virgin Hyperloop One. It’s hoping to build a pilot tube between the city of Greeley and the airport about 40 miles to the south, and possibly build an entire network across the state.

Once its feasibility study is completed, Ford says CDOT might have a clearer picture of the regulatory and other hurdles that need to be cleared. But if the country’s inability to construct high-speed rail—not to mention run conventional rail networks—is any indication, that will just be the beginning of what it takes to make real hyperloop or whatever idea comes next. Or, as Ford indicated, there are still 97 steps to go.


Read more: https://www.wired.com/story/arrivo-colorado-brogan-bambrogan-hyperloop-concept/

496 Replies to “How Arrivo Got Colorado to Back a Wild-Eyed Highway Scheme”

  1. lending payday

    bd65 compra is

    bd65 is generika zollfrei

    bd65 acheter is femm

    bd65

  2. what is cash advance interest

    bd65 how long effect of is

    bd65 at is sample pack

    bd65 order is online paypal

    bd65

  3. porzellan is is kauf

    37a0 is russian singers

  4. Hi! synthroid online pharmacy very good site.

  5. billig is bestellen

    37a0 is 25 mg price in rupees

  6. cbd oil interactions with medications best cbd oil uk

  7. https://whatisketodiettuj.com/ will keto diet help decrease glucose level

  8. we like it natual is

    37a0 bill to limit is use

  9. Hello there! online pharmacies in mexico beneficial site.

  10. quick loans in ma

    bd65 is for sale canada

    bd65 usefull link how to get is

    bd65 is free online index

    bd65

  11. https://ketodietrecipesxef.com/ why am i not losing weight on my keto diet?

  12. being is cozumel

    37a0 safe purchase of is

  13. https://ketodietecrt.com/ best multivitamin for men on keto diet

  14. Hello! ed online pharmacy good web page.

  15. where to buy cbd oil in canada cbd oil uses

  16. https://ketodietrecipesxef.com/ supplements for keto diet fish oil potassium magnesium

  17. SarraKnor2019 says:

    Hello. Nice site! And Bye.

  18. is brand name be online

    0584 pharmacie en ligne is uk

  19. https://ketodietplanecyh.com/ can you have mushrooms on keto diet

  20. https://ketodietlistdfk.com/ keto diet food list printable free

  21. Georgesicky says:

    Los Blancos, with captain Sergio Ramos suspended after deliberately collecting a yellow card in the first leg, had been looking to build on a slender 2-1 lead from that game in Amsterdam and stay on course for a potential fourth straight European triumph.

    However, after Raphael Varane’s header rattled the crossbar, Ajax raced into an early lead through Hakim Ziyech before Dusan Tadic set up David Neres for a second in the 18th minute.
    tinyurl
    Real Madrid were forced into two changes when Lucas Vazquez and Vinicius Junior went off injured, with substitute Gareth Bale hitting the post just before half-time.

    Ajax looked to have put the tie to bed when Tadic swept in a brilliant third goal just after the hour – which was eventually given following an extensive Video Assistant Referee review to check if the ball had gone out of play in the build-up.

  22. cash loans bend oregon

    bd65 is t shirts sale

    bd65 is atsoft tabs

    bd65 is frau online bestellen

    bd65

  23. nea personal loan

    bd65 3000mg blue herbal is male

    bd65 is 5mg daily use

    bd65 is is testbericht

    bd65

  24. online apotheke schweiz is

    0584 be is in in bangladesh

  25. quick loans in ma

    bd65 is there a female is

    bd65 liquid is 30mg

    bd65 is 50 preis

    bd65

  26. precio is 5 mg farmacia

    0584 dosage of is 36 hour

  27. cash loans bend oregon

    bd65 can be is nz

    bd65 visit our site chip is

    bd65 is deaths 2011

    bd65

  28. natural viagra alternatives

  29. can buy viagra in malaysia

  30. is come sostanza dopant

    cf9d is pulmonary edema

  31. RobertLix says:

    Hi there! good online pharmacy great website.

  32. https://bestcasino365us.com/ what casino game has the best odds for the player

  33. good place absolutely cooperative articles. combine bookmarks

  34. strongest cbd oil for sale cbd oil amazon

  35. viagra from indian company

  36. https://us24casinoonline.com/ best paying slot machines casino

  37. viagra uae price

  38. view homepage https://buylasixxgen.com – lasix 20mg clicking here lasix no prescription

  39. strongest cbd oil for sale cbd oil vape

  40. 3 viagra pills 4 sale

  41. In one case https://onlinecasino2019.us.org/ – free casino slots bonus games a Videoslots customer failed automated identity checks and instead provided a fraudulent driving licence, which was not detected.

  42. where to buy viagra for cheap

  43. Great blog you have here.. It’s hard to find good quality writing like yours nowadays.I seriously appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!

  44. just try viagra for ed

  45. AllensJuisy says:

    canadian pharmacy cialis https://cialisxgeneric.com – cialis canada no prescription

  46. viagra grande 50 mg

  47. Maria78hike says:

    kamagra oral jelly 100mg factory discount prices kamagra gel forum hr – kamagra oral jelly review kamagra kopen in de winkel nederland bof

  48. Maria78hike says:

    kamagra oral jelly 100mg factory discount prices kamagra gel forum hr – kamagra oral jelly review kamagra kopen in de winkel nederland bof

  49. sell viagra online affiliate

  50. is price in india 2012

    26f3 how much is do u take

  51. Katia87TrisY says:

    cheap levitra pills levitra 20 mg cost buy levitra online canada – generic levitra canada

  52. is pills overnight

    26f3 cheapest is pfizer uk

  53. viagra vendita canada

  54. Robertwaymn says:

    Howdy! best site to buy generic propecia very good site.

  55. preis is 25mg

    26f3 soft is vs is

  56. natural is substitutes uk

    26f3 is kamagra espaa

  57. buying viagra in macau

  58. Robertwaymn says:

    Hi! viagra propecia online gt great web site.

  59. Sasa676TrisY says:

    herbal viagra what is viagra used for free viagra – viagra australia

  60. viagra overdose 200mg

  61. be is on line reviews

    4a6d australia tienda de is

  62. MicleTrisY says:

    cipla cialis one a day cialis – cialis mail order

  63. Salo27TrisY says:

    lasix without script furosemide lasix – lasix 100mg online

  64. best online gambling sites for real money zone online casino bingo games

  65. OvanovaWaymn says:

    we like it discount is

    d41d cheap is 100mg 10 pack

  66. cipla cialis found it for you – buy cheap cialis online

  67. These three figures — William Rick Singer, Mark Riddell and Rudolph Meredith, respectively — are at the center of the nationwide scandal in which 33 parents are accused of using their wealth and means to help their children game the college admissions system.
    But those three names do not appear anywhere in the complaint text, though the document gives enough clues to make clear who is who. Instead, they are named as Cooperating Witness 1, 2 and 3, and each agreed to plead guilty and to cooperate with the government in the hope of obtaining leniency when they are sentenced, the complaint says.

  68. mejor viagra natura

  69. casino games no download no registration online gambling

  70. right spot absolutely neighbourly articles. add bookmarks

  71. good position sheer helpful articles. add bookmarks

  72. australia pfizer is

    ed70 is in omeopati

  73. uso dosi is

    ed70 befor after is

  74. comprar is espa241a

    99a2 is levitra generika

  75. cipla at is india

    99a2 tadalafil is uk low price

  76. mail order is india

    019f is en farmacias de andorra

  77. does is get old

    5592 is daily availability

  78. levitra is or is better

    5592 at is walmart

  79. use of is tadalafil

    5592 is mal di schiena dovuto

Leave a Reply