Opinion | Why White Americans Love To Claim Native Ancestry

Like Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), I grew up believing I was part Cherokee. Like her, I was persuaded by the family mythology that my grandfather’s “high cheekbones” were sufficient evidence of our Indian ancestry.

Then I read Vine Deloria Jr.’s book Custer Died for Your Sins, which punctured a hole in the genealogical fabric I’d inherited. In this classic book about the American Indian Movement, Deloria wrote about his time at the National Congress of American Indians, during which white people came through his office almost every day claiming they had a “Cherokee grandmother.” I recognized that my fond belief in a Cherokee ancestor was, in fact, a cliche, and I mostly let go of this false narrative about my family’s heritage.

But not everyone gives up on that narrative. Elizabeth Warren certainly hasn’t. The senator’s doubling-down on her claims to Native American ancestry — and the Cherokee Nation’s disavowal of her claims — highlights that the way that claims to indigeneity for white people, and specifically, for a white person like Elizabeth Warren, supports white supremacist ideas and practices.

For many white Americans, there is something appealing about being a “little bit Cherokee”; some observers call it the “Cherokee Syndrome.” In the 2010 census, more than 819,000 Americans self-identified as Cherokee ― but the combined population of the three federally recognized Cherokee tribes (the Cherokee Nation and United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee in Oklahoma, and the Eastern Band of Cherokee in North Carolina) amounts to fewer than 400,000.

I recognized that my fond belief in a Cherokee ancestor was, in fact, a cliche, and I mostly let go of this false narrative about my family’s heritage.

Material benefits are part of the allure. The ability to assert a Native American identity on official forms can lead to result in access to additional resources. For instance, in the late-nineties, a company owned by House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy’s (R-Calif.) in-laws won more than $7 million in no-bid and other federal contracts at U.S. military installations and other government properties in California based on a dubious claim of Native American identity by McCarthy’s brother-in-law. At Harvard Law School, Warren was celebrated as the first “minority” woman to receive tenure. This was based on her own claims of Native American identity on employment forms, although she and Harvard Law have denied her identity had anything to do with her promotion.   

Then there are the more ephemeral appeals to claiming Cherokee identity. “I believe that there is a retreat from white guilt that is happening here,” writes University of Texas anthropologist Circe Sturm in her book Becoming Indian: The Struggle over Cherokee Identity. “Whiteness is responsible for indigenous dispossession and the lack of societal connection that characterizes modernity,” she said in an interview. Sturm calls people who claim Cherokee identity without prior tribal affiliation “race shifters,” who are seeking connection to an identity outside whiteness. Claiming an indigenous identity, however flimsy the evidence, relieves some of the discomfort of being a white settler.

CNBC

Race shifters are commonplace in American history; perhaps the most infamous recent example is Rachel Dolezal, who claimed in a 2015 interview that she’d been born in a “tepee” and spent parts of her childhood hunting for food with a “bow and arrow.” These claims turned out to be false. Sturm argues that race shifters associate Indianness with a set of values and a feeling of community belonging that is “the near opposite of the anomic individualism … associated with the modern condition of whiteness.” Dolezal, like other race shifters, was able to get a paid position with the NAACP using yet another racial identity. Claiming Native American identity means that some white people have access to material resources and the emotional distance from a legacy as an oppressor. 

When Elizabeth Warren took the bait of her political rival by using a DNA test to “prove” her claims, she endorsed a way of thinking about race, DNA and Native ancestry that reinforces white supremacy. The notion that an individual can discover their tribal affiliation through a DNA test reinforces the white supremacist notion of “race” as a biological trait tied to a specific gene, discoverable from saliva. It’s the same idea at the core of the Ancestry.com advertisements that you’ve surely seen on TV. This simplistic view of how genetic markers work strengthens retrograde notions about about “blood quantum” and race.

Research by Kim TallBear, a professor of Native Studies at the University of Alberta, has established that there are no genetic markers of Native ancestry. In her book, Native American DNA: Tribal Belonging and the False Sense of Genetic Science, TallBear observes that tribal membership is a legal category, not a genetic one. She points out that it is impossible to disentangle individual genetic information from the constellations of family relations, reservation histories, tribal rules and government regulations in which genes are formed.

The notion that an individual can discover their tribal affiliation through a DNA test reinforces the white supremacist notion of ‘race’ as a biological trait tied to a specific gene.

When the question of using DNA to establish Sen. Warren’s lineage first emerged in 2016, Professor TallBear wrote about the fallacy of using genetic markers to establish tribal membership. “Because we are all genetically related, there are no tribe-specific markers, i.e., no Cherokee, Pequot, or Lakota markers,” she wrote. So, Warren’s claims that she has a “gene” that proves she is Cherokee is false, but her championing of this idea to score political points reifies a particular set of ideas about Indianness and biology.

Insisting on the idea that there is a genetic marker for Indian identity, as Senator Warren is doing, is another way of reinforcing white supremacist ideas. And here’s the thing I learned from my own family’s Cherokee Syndrome: there is a lot of overlap between believing you’re a “little bit Cherokee” and white supremacy. My grandfather with the “high cheekbones” was also in the Ku Klux Klan. Most people think of these two identities ― Native American and KKK member ― as on opposing ends of a racial spectrum, but in the American context, there is a lot of overlap between the two. White families tell their children about a connection to a mythic Native American past as a way to lay claim to territory and to a sense of belonging. It is a way of asserting: we are the true First Peoples.

White families tell their children about a connection to a mythic Native American past as a way to lay claim to territory and to a sense of belonging.

Elizabeth Warren is trying to weave her family lore of a Cherokee past into her political future. And, in that way, she is not so different from the “race shifters” that Sturm documents in her research, or from my family.

No matter what her DNA test says, Warren is no more Cherokee than I am, which is not at all. But by claiming a Cherokee identity when she has none, she is propping up white supremacy.

“It’s not about what identity you claim,” TallBear said in a 2016 interview about the issue, “it’s about who claims you.” Senator Warren isn’t being claimed by the Cherokee nation, and that’s what matters.

Jessie Daniels is a Professor at The City University Of New York, and the author of the forthcoming book Tweetstorm: The Rise of the “Alt-Right” and the Mainstreaming of White Nationalism.

Read more: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/opinion-warren-cherokee-dna_us_5bc63a69e4b0a8f17ee6ba9a

183 Replies to “Opinion | Why White Americans Love To Claim Native Ancestry”

  1. cialis and others http://cialisle.com/ generic cialis. reasons cialis may not work.

  2. compare viagra and vimax http://www.viagrabs.com/ generic viagra.
    how can i tell if my boyfriend takes viagra.

  3. sta je bolje viagra ili cialis http://cialislet.com/ cialis
    prices. acquisto tadalafil originale.

  4. should i take l arginine with sildenafil viagrauga.com how to get sildenafil usa

  5. b http://cialisps.com/ generic cialis online
    cialis bayan için
    buy generic cialis

  6. tadalafil and alcohol interaction cialis online tadalafil 5 mg diario efectos secundarios

  7. my boyfriend is on sildenafil
    https://tadapox.wixsite.com/tadapox tadapox.wixsite.com
    how to get sildenafil in dublin
    buy online order amoxil
    psychological benefits of sildenafil

  8. taking sildenafil with heart failure [url=http://viagrapid.com/]viagra
    online usa[/url] 22 years old sildenafil

  9. chinese herbal alternative to viagra viagragenupi.com
    traveling abroad with viagra

  10. tadalafil 20 or 40 mg viagra generic perbedaan viagra dengan cialis

  11. valor cialis diario buy cheap cialis tadalafil lo pueden tomar las mujeres

  12. viagra online no prescription buy generic viagra online cheap
    viagra pills [url=https://www.bioshieldpill.com/]where can i buy viagra online[/url]

  13. cialis 2 5 in italia cialis generic mas efectivo viagra o cialis

  14. programa lilly tadalafil generic cialis online buy cialis in melbourne

  15. can a man get a woman pregnant if he takes sildenafil http://triviagra.com get sildenafil without anyone knowing generic viagra where is the best place to buy
    viagra online

  16. best place to buy tadalafil in australia order generic cialis where can you buy sildenafil from

  17. cialis cosa e buy generic cialis cheapest country to buy sildenafil

  18. can you buy viagra in toronto cheap online sales cialis tadalafil and fluconazole

  19. nfqgrtgt melhor preço de tadalafil http://cialissom.com/ cialis 10mg cheap cialis 5mg tadalafil 5 mg precio
    en colombia

  20. viagra in thane
    [url=http://doctor7online.com/]generic viagra[/url]
    what are the side effects of viagra and cialis
    doctor7online.com

  21. does sildenafil show up in drug test
    http://viagrarow.com
    sildenafil trong thuc pham
    [url=http://viagrarow.com]generic viagra 100[/url]

  22. is sicuro

    2659 we use it 5 mg is

  23. does tadalafil cause constipation generic cialis online werking sildenafil 100mg

  24. on line is uk sales

    aacd nuovo is rosso

  25. precautions taking viagra http://viagratru.com generic viagra canada, taking liquid tadalafil

  26. vente tadalafil en ligne france online cialis cialis ojos rojos.

  27. is genrico en australia

    b5db is pfizer price au

  28. is genrico en australia

    b5db the best site be is

  29. be is in paris

    b5db achat is internet danger

  30. s http://jcialisf.com cialis how it works free cialis sample pack brand
    name cialis

  31. can i cut a 20mg cialis tablet in half does generic viagra work viagra in animals

  32. at is for low price

    aa72 online be where is cheap

  33. at is message board

    aa72 substitutes is

  34. is online gekauft

    b950 is plus price

  35. use caverject and is

    b950 we choice being is

  36. is pharmacie paris

    b950 liquid is kamagra uk

  37. is pfizer 25 mg

    b950 is boots at

  38. be brand is 20 mg cost

    0d1c cheap lily lcos is

  39. only today be daily is

    0d1c is at wholesale

  40. prescripcin de india is

    0d1c is 10mg in the usa

  41. american at is

    58b8 lloyds is price

  42. wow look it is pliis

    58b8 atenolol is

  43. online is review best

    58b8 is effetti forum

  44. prices is canada

    58b8 just try is be uk 50mg

  45. is tarif pharmaci

    9113 at is legal in uk

  46. is tadalafil dosage

    9113 discount is at

  47. venta de is 10 mg

    9113 is en colim

  48. is utilisation

    9113 cheap is black australia

  49. is commercial song

    e558 only here be is in us

  50. legal be is online

    e558 comprar is farmacia foro

  51. legal be is online

    e558 pay by paypal at is

  52. is ato en india

    f80a is 40 mg be

  53. is 6 free samples

    f80a only now is 20 mg canada

  54. online is in india

  55. where can i get is

    2cee recommended site brand is

  56. cheap is professional uk

    c8d8 is usa overnight delivery

  57. advice on being is

    c8d8 best tab of is

  58. levitra is online is

    c8d8 is multiple intercourse

  59. is en ligne pour la vente

    f96d tadacip vs is

  60. is en ligne pour la vente

    f96d best sale is

  61. side effects is

    f96d is soft tabs online kaufen

  62. is diabt

    f96d is kohlpharma 4

  63. be super is cheap

    f96d can i make a 20 mg is 10

  64. how to obtain sildenafil
    https://tadapox.wixsite.com/silagra silagra for sale
    can you take sildenafil and lisinopril together
    silagra pills for sale
    what is the key ingredient in sildenafil

  65. You can see about our brand spankin’ new webpage and get to know how crazy you can be: blackjack online

  66. is en alleman

    3c7e is langzeitwirkung

  67. il is ato sicuro

    54dd ou acheter is serieux

  68. click here is online usa

    54dd be is adelaide

  69. is 20mg dosage

    54dd venta de is argentina

  70. can is be taken by women

    8d74 fda approved is

  71. is prescriptions usa

    8d74 is versandapotheke nl

  72. farmacia is espan

    8d74 be spray is for men

  73. site achat is

    8d74 only now cheapest is price

  74. is y la comida

    9e6b be is 5 be in singapore

  75. is 5mg terapia

    9e6b is telefonisch bestellen

  76. cheap is super p online

    9e6b is online women

  77. preise is c20

    9e6b is preis bestellen

  78. is online in canada

    f612 foro is

  79. prix is 50 100 mg

    f612 brand at is

  80. link for you iscom

    eb98 order is 60 mg online

  81. at is soft purchase

    eb98 is cheapest in uk

  82. best is prices

    eb98 is at sale

  83. comprar is argentina

    9f8c price list is

  84. is ou is lequel choisi

    9f8c is 20mg

  85. i recommend 100mg is cost

    9f8c global sales of is

  86. we recommend is iop

    cab8 try it is usa

  87. is achat net

    cab8 vente is pharmacie

  88. just try what is is

    cab8 is 10 ou 20

  89. wow best prices for is

    cab8 is dose for daily use

  90. is dosage 10 m

    cab8 is ato vendita

  91. is envio argentina

    cab8 is soft canada paypal

  92. try it cheap fast is

    c471 i recommend order cheap is

  93. is 5 mg order online

    c471 cost of is pill

  94. at is authenticity

    c471 is ou kamagr

  95. usefull link is best price

    c471 is rx prezzo

  96. achat is allemagne

    11bf is hospital

  97. where can i be is cream

    11bf commander is

  98. comments is approved

    11bf only here is be

  99. is alternatives sale

    11bf donde comprar is sin

  100. be is off brand online

    11bf at is and is

  101. compri non is ato

    11bf vente is en pharmaci

  102. sirve es y que is que para

  103. el is sirve para durar mas

    ef1c ab wann kann man is kaufen

  104. le is doctissim

    ef1c is naturale india

  105. is professional best price

    ef1c erix comprim is

  106. compare prices herbal is

    ef1c be is in walmart

  107. is naturale india

    ef1c click now is where to be

  108. other names for tadalafil http://cialsagen.com/ tadalafil hape

  109. cheap soft tab is

    ef1c nebenwirkungen is ciali

  110. be cheap is brand

    320a is naturale in erboristeri

  111. overnight cheap is

    320a click now real is online

  112. is receta europa

    320a is e impotenz

  113. acheter is internet forum

    320a is drug effects

  114. least expensive is online

    320a is de 05 mg

  115. is 10 mg every other day

    320a be is 100mg online

  116. is 20 mg para comprar

    320a is ato sinalo

  117. lowest price of is

    320a cheapest at is uk

  118. 15 mg is enough

    320a can a women take is

  119. cheap is soft

    320a prix is 5mg

  120. alternative to is in uk

    a672 alternative to is in uk

  121. plant is side effects

    a672 acheter is pilule bleue

  122. mountainwest apothecary is

    a672 is color

  123. wow canadain is india

    a672 is acheter pfizer

  124. is caps for sale

    a672 can u use is with zoloft

  125. pillole is immagini

    a672 prezzo is da 50 m

  126. is 100mg power

    a672 is livraison en 24

  127. is caps for sale

    a672 reviews forums at is

  128. online purchase of pro is

    5c8f low cost is soft tab

  129. billiges is tadalafil

    5c8f il is funzion

  130. at is wholesale price

    5c8f just try order is online

  131. be is overnight shipping

    5c8f be is overnight shipping

  132. compra viagra on line

  133. kwikmed coupon viagra

  134. cyclobenzaprine and viagra viagra online complications taking sildenafil.

  135. is is toscan

    45f0 is prix is

  136. samples of is cheap

    45f0 50 mg is online

  137. uk pfizer is online paypal

    45f0 be single is uk

  138. abc for the is

    45f0 from is india at

  139. is senza ricetta svizzera

    45f0 is soft til salg

  140. tomar is yahoo respuestas

    45f0 is prices singapore

  141. is venta por internet

    45f0 online is kopen

  142. i recommend is canadian

    e863 is 5 mg daily dosage

  143. acheter du is en allemagne

    e863 take 20 mg and 5mg is

  144. order is on line usa

    e863 mail order is 10mg

  145. is dosage options software

    e863 take 20 mg and 5mg is

  146. is 20mg tunisie

    e863 pfizer is online

  147. mail order is 10mg

    e863 acquista is sicuro

  148. illegal purchase is online

    e863 is be store

  149. is with atenolol

    e863 over the counter female is

  150. is kosten 20mg

    e863 is barato low price

  151. achat is expres

    e863 is blues

  152. is professional ata

    e863 shipping is to nz

  153. is al contrario

    9f03 bestalla is online

  154. comprar atos is

    9f03 kann man is sicher kaufen

  155. link for you is doses

    9f03 discount order is

  156. is commercial on xm radio

    9f03 el ato del is

  157. cipla is at

    9f03 is commercial on xm radio

  158. at is phillipines

    9f03 kann man is sicher kaufen

  159. brand is our price 794

    54a1 be is be paypal

  160. be at is in taiwan

    54a1 wow herbal is

  161. is libid

    54a1 cheap price is pills

  162. is en farmacia en svizzera

    54a1 i use it order at is

  163. comprar levitra is

    54a1 farmacia online roma is

  164. is bestellen rezeptfrei

    54a1 is without script

  165. viagra psychischer strung

  166. is kaufen bremen

    6741 is quel pri

  167. is quando prenderl

    df7f is 2mg

  168. new drug is

    df7f precio bajo diariamente is

  169. how to be is in brisbane

    37a0 is canada drugs link

  170. quelle est la différence entre le viagra et le tadalafil [url=http://cialsonlinebei.com]cialis online prescription[/url] tadalafil venda controlada http://cialsonlinebei.com generic cialis

  171. is cipla

    ed70 click here is cheap online

  172. is super active kaufen

    ed70 is tablets au

  173. is copla india prices

    99a2 is medication australia

  174. eriacta vs is be online

    019f acheter is en espagn

  175. svizzera is

    019f be is through paypal

Leave a Reply