Theranos documentary review: The Inventors horrifying optimism

A blood-splattered Theranos machine nearly pricks an employee struggling to fix it. This gruesome graphical rendering is what you’ll walk away with from HBO’s “The Inventor.” It finally gives a visual to the startup’s laboratory fraud detailed in words by John Carreyrou’s book “Bad Blood.”

The documentary that premiered tonight at Sundance Film Festival explores how the move-fast-and-break-things ethos of Silicon Valley is “really dangerous when people’s lives are in the balance,” as former employee and whistleblower Tyler Shultz says in the film. Theranos promised a medical testing device that made a single drop of blood from your finger more precise than a painful old-school syringe in your vein. What patients ended up using was so inaccurate it put their health in jeopardy.

But perhaps even more frightening is the willingness of Theranos CEO Elizabeth Holmes to delude herself and everyone around her in service of a seemingly benevolent mission. The documentary captures how good ideas can make people do bad things.

“The Inventor: Out for Blood in Silicon Valley” juxtaposes truthful interviews with the employees who eventually rebelled against Holmes with footage and media appearances of her blatantly lying to the world. It manages to stick to the emotion of the story rather than getting lost in the scientific discrepancies of Theranos’ deception.

The film opens and closes with close-ups of Holmes, demonstrating how the facts change her same gleaming smile and big blue eyes from the face of innovative potential to that of a sociopathic criminal. “I don’t have many secrets,” she tells the camera at the start.

Though the film mentions early that her $9 billion-plus valuation company would wind up worth less than zero, it does a keen job of building empathy for her that it can tear down later. You see her tell sob stories of death in the family and repeat her line about building an end to having to say goodbye to loved ones too soon. You hear how she’s terrified of needles and how growing up, “my best friends were books.”

But then cracks start to emerge as old powerful men, from professors to former cabinet members, faun over Holmes and become enthralled in her cult of personality as validation snowballs. Oscar-winning director Alex Gibney has a knack for creeping dread from his experience making “Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room” and “Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison of Belief.” He portrays Holmes’ delusions of grandeur with shots of her portrait beside those of Archimedes, Beethoven and her idol Steve Jobs.

The first red flag comes when Holmes names her initial device Edison after the historic inventor the film assures you was quite a fraud himself. Soon, sources from inside the company relay how the Edison and subsequent Theranos hardware never worked right but that demos were faked for customers and investors. Instead of sticking to a firm timeline, Gibney bounces around to hammer home the emotional arcs of employees from excited to dubious, and of Holmes from confidence to paranoia.

Carreyrou’s “Bad Blood” meticulously chronicled every tiny warning sign that worried Theranos’ staff in order to build a case. But the author’s Wall Street Journal day job bled through, sapping the book of emotion and preventing it from seizing the grandeur of the tale’s climactic moments.

Gibney fills in the blanks with cringe-inducing scenes of Theranos’ faulty hardware. A “nanotainer” of blood rolls off a table and fractures, a biohazard awaiting whoever tries to pick it up. The depiction of working in Theranos’ unregulated laboratory scored the biggest gasps from the Sundance audience. Former employees describe how Theranos recruited drifters they suspected of hepatitis as guinea pigs. Their stale blood evaporates into the air surrounding machines dripping with inky red, covered in broken test tubes. Gibney nails the graphics, zooming in on a needle spraying droplets as a robotic arm sputters through malfunctions. I almost had to look away as the film renders a hand reaching into the machine and only just dodging an erratic syringe.

A still from “The Inventor: Out for Blood in Silicon Valley” by Alex Gibney, an official selection of the Documentary Premieres program at the 2019 Sundance Film Festival. Courtesy of Sundance Institute | photo by Drew Kelly.

At times, Gibney goes a bit too melodramatic. The toy music box twinkling foreshadows a dream becoming a nightmare, but it gets maddening after an hour straight. The pacing feels uneven, sometimes bogged down in Holmes’ personal relationships when later it seems to speed through the company’s collapse.

Though elsewhere, the director harnesses the nervous laughter coping mechanism of the former employees to inject humor into the grim tale. With accuracy so low, Shultz jokes that “if people are testing themselves for syphilis with Theranos, there’s going to be a lot more syphilis in the world.” Visual dramatizations of journalists’ audio recordings of Holmes and the eventual legal disputes bring this evidence to life.

Alex Gibney, director of “The Inventor: Out for Blood in Silicon Valley,” an official selection of the Documentary Premieres program at the 2019 Sundance Film Festival. Courtesy of Sundance Institute.

The most touching scene sees Fortune’s Roger Parloff on the brink of implosion as he grapples with giving Holmes her first magazine cover story — momentum she used to eventually get Theranos’ useless hardware in front of real patients who depended on its results.

The Inventor succeeds at instilling the lesson without getting too preachy. It’s fine to be hopeful, but don’t ignore your concerns no matter how much you want something to be real. It takes an incredibly complex sequence of events and makes it at once gripping and informative. If you haven’t read “Bad Blood” or found it drab, “The Inventor” conveys the gravity of the debacle with a little more flare.

Yet the documentary also gives Holmes a bit too much benefit of the doubt, suggesting that hey, at least she was trying to do good in the world. In the after-film panel, Gibney said, “She had a noble vision . . . I think that was part of why she was able to convince so many people and convince herself that what she was doing was great, which allowed her to lie so effectively.” Carreyrou followed up that “she was not intending to perpetrate a long con.”

Yet that’s easier to say for both the director and the author when neither of their works truly investigated the downstream health impacts of Theranos’ false positives and false negatives. If they’d tracked down people who delayed critical treatment or had their lives upended by the fear of a disease they didn’t have, I doubt Holmes would be cut so much slack.

Some degree of “Fake it ’til you make it” might be essential to build hard technology startups. You must make people believe in something that doesn’t exist if you’re to pull in the funding and talent necessary to make it a reality. But it’s not just medical, hardware, or “atoms not bits” startups that must be allegiant to the truth. As Facebook and WhatsApps’ role in spreading misinformation that led to mob killings in India and Myanmar proved, having a grand mission doesn’t make you incapable of doing harm. A line must be drawn between optimism and dishonesty before it leads to drawing chalk outlines on the ground.

Read more: https://techcrunch.com/2019/01/24/theranos-the-inventor-review/

501 Replies to “Theranos documentary review: The Inventors horrifying optimism”

  1. comprar is levitra

    54dd mejor precio de is india

  2. how soon before take is

    54dd is daily reviews

  3. prix canadien sur is

    54dd at is cipla brand

  4. is professionnel

    54dd try it is prescriptions

  5. only for you is gel

    54dd ou acheter du is

  6. Hi there! online pharmacy uk beneficial website.

  7. is online contrareembolso

    54dd is 5 mg prezzo in farmaci

  8. be is super active online

    54dd order is 20 mg

  9. i recommend viagra from canada

  10. recommended site viagra uk

  11. at with is

    8d74 foro donde comprar is

  12. is ato con paypal

    8d74 farmacia is espan

  13. is dubai uae

    9e6b cheap nonat is

  14. is soft stores

    9e6b is soft cheap us at

  15. is dangereux net

    9e6b muestras de is

  16. fast paydayloans

    bd65 is genrico indio

    bd65 is iegm

    bd65 achat is 150 mg

    bd65

  17. Hi there! buy tadalafil no prescription beneficial web site.

  18. Howdy! buy cialis medication very good site.

  19. payday loans in sapulpa ok

    bd65 is t shirts sale

    bd65 el is es mejor

    bd65 be 25 mg is online

    bd65

  20. Hi! buy tadalafil very good web page.

  21. where can i get a unsecured personal loan with bad credit

    bd65 isnde zero assoluto

    bd65 is 4cpr riv

    bd65 discount levitra is is

    bd65

  22. best sites be is online

  23. viagra to buy pay on delievery

  24. viagra buy viagra online

  25. payday cash advance online no credit check

    bd65 is no prescription

    bd65 is generique on sale

    bd65 being is costa rica

    bd65

  26. just try viagra for ed

  27. lending payday

    bd65 drug sex is

    bd65 is en pastilla

    bd65 is por ebay

    bd65

  28. acheter is au canada

    eb98 look here canada cheap is

  29. female is perth australia

    eb98 be is manila philippines

  30. is taken by women

    eb98 is tadalafil generika

  31. is 5 mg onde comprar

    eb98 is tadalafil generika

  32. is 20mg online apotheke

    eb98 is tadalafil generika

  33. the best site low cost is

    eb98 is kosten 20 mg

  34. is bei glaukom

    eb98 online be is

  35. purchase is in mexico

    cab8 is per ragazzi

  36. lending payday

    bd65 is precio soles

    bd65 is for

    bd65 is por ebay

    bd65

  37. brand viagra 100mg cheap

  38. experience with at is

  39. payday advance antioch

    bd65 villages florida is

    bd65 i use it 100 mg is

    bd65 is is shop

    bd65

  40. cash loans in cookeville tn

    bd65 is riot

    bd65 is diario precio

    bd65 the best site is in canada

    bd65

  41. low price generic viagra

  42. installment loans how they work

    bd65 which shops sell is uk

    bd65 nome ato is

    bd65 is atenolol

    bd65

  43. is tablets best price

  44. viagra tablets best price

  45. efeito do viagra generico

  46. cash advance servicing wilmington de

    bd65 be is bali

    bd65 cheap is 20mg pills us

    bd65 be real is tabs

    bd65

  47. only now bio viagra herbal

  48. loans instant approval

    bd65 is pdf

    bd65 is available in australia

    bd65 generisch is online

    bd65

  49. payday loans in robertsdale al

    bd65 best uk cheapest is 100mg

    bd65 is online south africa

    bd65 is por ebay

    bd65

  50. click now viagra sales online

  51. loans in hawaii for bad credit

    bd65 women taking is 2012

    bd65 achetez 80 mg is

    bd65 online is 1

    bd65

  52. 500 dollar personal loan no credit check

    bd65 is pricing at costco

    bd65 at is sample pack

    bd65 is onde comprar no brasil

    bd65

  53. quick loans in ma

    bd65 be is bali

    bd65 is barato tadalafil india

    bd65 what is shelf life of is

    bd65

  54. cash loans barrie

    bd65 is for sale at walmart

    bd65 is 5mg daily use

    bd65 try it order is cheap

    bd65

  55. low apr on small loans

    bd65 is pricing at costco

    bd65 is cost australia

    bd65 effet is verg

    bd65

  56. generic viagra on a plane

  57. us or canada discount viagra

  58. how do you get money fast

    bd65 is sur les homme

    bd65 is for

    bd65 costco at is prices

    bd65

  59. 33 viagra order online

  60. viagrakaufen 100mg

  61. order viagra in singapore

  62. is necesita receta

  63. only for you viagra in canada

  64. earn online money

    bd65 very cheap tablets like is

    bd65 tomar is mujer

    bd65 comprare is svizzer

    bd65

  65. buy maestro viagra

  66. costs of viagra at rite aid

  67. payday loans lakeland fl

    bd65 wow look it is endurance

    bd65 online being is

    bd65 is por corre

    bd65

  68. bad credit loan wisconsin

    bd65 is without prsecription

    bd65 is 5mg daily use

    bd65 want is wholesale

    bd65

  69. cash loan logos

    bd65 kobe is online

    bd65 is online deals

    bd65 being is costa rica

    bd65

  70. can buy viagra in malaysia

  71. payday loan in oregon city

    bd65 cheap red is

    bd65 young and take is

    bd65 being is prescription

    bd65

  72. top payday loan companies

    bd65 can be is nz

    bd65 is nez bouch

    bd65 at without is

    bd65

  73. top in WI cash advance

    bd65 is doctors sacramento ca

    bd65 is naturale forum

    bd65 comments is purchase

    bd65

  74. personal loans redding ca

    bd65 is a prix discount

    bd65 is receta medica

    bd65 is free online index

    bd65

  75. viagra gnrique inde

  76. viagra billig keine vorschrift

  77. viagra prices costco

  78. payday loan mcalester ok

    bd65 is cost of

    bd65 does the at is work

    bd65 is is shop

    bd65

  79. teachers union viagra

  80. buy real brand viagra

  81. viagra en los jovene

  82. cash loans in cookeville tn

    bd65 we like it is india

    bd65 is flssig kaufen

    bd65 is pfizer preiswert

    bd65

  83. make some extra cash

    bd65 kobe is online

    bd65 is iegm

    bd65 at is discount

    bd65

  84. kosten pro dosis fr is

  85. emergency loan shsu

    bd65 at is pics

    bd65 online being is

    bd65 is pills for men in india

    bd65

  86. quick loan without guarantor

    bd65 can you be is from boots

    bd65 order is melbourne

    bd65 is anonym kaufen

    bd65

  87. earn online money

    bd65 only for you cheap is 50mg

    bd65 is annual sales 2011 mg

    bd65 is bestellen schweiz

    bd65

  88. cash advance stores in madison wi

    bd65 is given to women

    bd65 is ato paypa

    bd65 at is online 50mg

    bd65

  89. advanced payroll

    bd65 is for sale canada

    bd65 precio de la is

    bd65 is pfizer preiswert

    bd65

  90. dallas cash advance

    bd65 soft is tabs from canada

    bd65 is atsoft tabs

    bd65 is pills for men in india

    bd65

  91. i want a loan

    bd65 we like it is india

    bd65 is 4cpr riv

    bd65 200 mg is safe

    bd65

  92. payday loan companies in oregon

    bd65 is online canada reviews

    bd65 is 5 mg be

    bd65 is is testbericht

    bd65

  93. payday loans in monroe louisiana

    bd65 is precio soles

    bd65 tomar is mujer

    bd65 brand is online usa

    bd65

  94. easy home money loans

    bd65 is you can be at walmart

    bd65 is ato en chihuahua

    bd65 anyone purchase is online

    bd65

  95. cash loans in cookeville tn

    bd65 is doctors sacramento ca

    bd65 vrai is 20m

    bd65 i use it is mastercard

    bd65

  96. what dose is should i use

    c471 is south africa

  97. unsecured loans for bad credit calculator

    bd65 only today price of is

    bd65 is in ukraine

    bd65 brand is online usa

    bd65

  98. cash loan logos

    bd65 pros and cons of is

    bd65 comprar is por paypal

    bd65 how do i get is from my gp

    bd65

  99. blank check loans

    bd65 is genrico indio

    bd65 is jeden tag kaufen

    bd65 be is online for free

    bd65

  100. is ou kamagr

    c471 achat is sur le ne

  101. cash loans barrie

    bd65 women taking is 2012

    bd65 i want to be at is

    bd65 difference in is mg

    bd65

  102. low apr on small loans

    bd65 is spanien

    bd65 online at is 5 mg

    bd65 is for sale uk only

    bd65

  103. cash advance lynchburg

    bd65 donde comprar is en nz

    bd65 online being is

    bd65 at is discount

    bd65

  104. payday loans in rgv

    bd65 sales is is

    bd65 be australian is

    bd65 is for sale uk only

    bd65

  105. personal loans redding ca

    bd65 is precio soles

    bd65 is 4cpr riv

    bd65 online is 1

    bd65

  106. payday loans in robertsdale al

    bd65 rezeptfrei is preis

    bd65 at is sample pack

    bd65 is phone orders

    bd65

  107. rr payday advance

    bd65 cheap red is

    bd65 is 5mg daily use

    bd65 is pfizer turkey

    bd65

  108. payday loan companies in oregon

    bd65 is cost ontario

    bd65 click now is woman

    bd65 200 mg is safe

    bd65

  109. is everyday reviews

    c471 retail price for is

  110. instant cash loans weekend

    bd65 only today price of is

    bd65 is price reduction

    bd65 farmacia in linea per is

    bd65

  111. is e vin

    c471 is pills ingreediants

  112. personal loans in greenwood sc

    bd65 mail order is from canada

    bd65 at is research

    bd65 homeopathic is for men

    bd65

  113. if i take 40 mg is

    c471 preissuche is 5mg

  114. competitive loan rates

    bd65 cheap 25mg is

    bd65 is farmacia svizzera

    bd65 is 100 mc

    bd65

  115. my approved loan

    bd65 is price mexico

    bd65 liquid is 30mg

    bd65 at is discount

    bd65

  116. what is the biggest personal loan you can get

    bd65 at iskamagra uk

    bd65 is 5mg order online

    bd65 what is shelf life of is

    bd65

  117. nea personal loan

    bd65 wow look it is soft tabs

    bd65 wow discount is is

    bd65 is pfizer turkey

    bd65

  118. quick loans shelby nc

    bd65 wow is in canada

    bd65 is 20 mg tab price

    bd65 il is danneggia la vist

    bd65

  119. i want a loan

    bd65 discount order is

    bd65 is receta medica

    bd65 is pfizer preiswert

    bd65

  120. emergency loan shsu

    bd65 who bes is online

    bd65 be at is europe

    bd65 at without is

    bd65

  121. just try be is australia

    11bf 1 pill is bestellen

  122. payday advance antioch

    bd65 legit website be is

    bd65 is ato paypa

    bd65 effet is verg

    bd65

  123. low apr on small loans

    bd65 we like it is india

    bd65 is jeden tag kaufen

    bd65 being is prescription

    bd65

  124. unsecured loans for bad credit calculator

    bd65 is canada di sconto

    bd65 at is research

    bd65 comments is purchase

    bd65

  125. cfsa payday loan lenders

    bd65 is without prsecription

    bd65 is 5mg order online

    bd65 is for hypertension

    bd65

  126. make some extra cash

    bd65 acheter du is aucanada

    bd65 is at wholesale

    bd65 at without is

    bd65

  127. payday loans lakeland fl

    bd65 is is manila

    bd65 is at wholesale

    bd65 achat is 150 mg

    bd65

  128. missouri payday loan hours

    bd65 soft is tabs from canada

    bd65 order is melbourne

    bd65 bula do is ato

    bd65

  129. payday loans in richlands va

    bd65 donde comprar is en nz

    bd65 is 5mg order online

    bd65 is mode administratio

    bd65

  130. personal loan with credit score of 630

    bd65 is given to women

    bd65 durata is

    bd65 is deaths 2011

    bd65

  131. cash wrap counter

    bd65 is price mexico

    bd65 is flssig kaufen

    bd65 il is danneggia la vist

    bd65

  132. ameribest payday loans olathe

    bd65 is without prsecription

    bd65 is jeden tag kaufen

    bd65 what is shelf life of is

    bd65

  133. cash advance loans direct lender no teletrack

    bd65 usefull link discount is

    bd65 be sublingual is canada

    bd65 is for sale uk only

    bd65

  134. fast payday loans wichita ks

    bd65 at is samples canada

    bd65 street value of is 20

    bd65 canadian is safe

    bd65

  135. personal loans redding ca

    bd65 is frau mann

    bd65 is in ukraine

    bd65 is atenolol

    bd65

  136. easy cash payday advance

    bd65 herbal is online australia

    bd65 be sublingual is canada

    bd65 order is online paypal

    bd65

  137. problems with is

    11bf normal is dosage

  138. guaranteed loans ost

    bd65 is cost ontario

    bd65 is en paragua

    bd65 is online effects

    bd65

  139. buy viagra online free

  140. 500 dollar personal loan no credit check

    bd65 is pdf

    bd65 is ato paypa

    bd65 how do i get is from my gp

    bd65

  141. viagra levitra differenze

  142. i want a loan

    bd65 discount online is

    bd65 order is jelly online

    bd65 venta is online espana

    bd65

  143. emergency loan shsu

    bd65 is precio soles

    bd65 liquid is 30mg

    bd65 is 100 mc

    bd65

  144. try it viagra price online

  145. top in WI cash advance

    bd65 we like it is purchase

    bd65 take is without need it

    bd65 is bestellen mastercard

    bd65

  146. cheap online generic viagra

  147. will cost viagra go down

  148. mercury drug store is

  149. compra viagra on line

  150. forum viagra pour femme

  151. viagra precio receta

  152. viagra svizzera prezzo

  153. kosten pro dosis fr viagra

  154. viagra no prescription paypal

  155. memenucom buy viagra mexico

  156. viagra brand discount

  157. buy cialis get viagra free

  158. same day loans saturday

    bd65 is t shirts sale

    bd65 eye problems is

    bd65 how do i get is from my gp

    bd65

  159. rr payday advance

    bd65 esiste is naturale

    bd65 is original barato

    bd65 enter site is seizures

    bd65

  160. buy viagra 25mg tablets

  161. how to get a quick easy loan

    bd65 is 50mg cos

    bd65 we use it prices online is

    bd65 is females uk

    bd65

  162. is compresse posologi

  163. prescription en ligne viagra

  164. try it generic viagra mexico

  165. is no prescription paypal

  166. herbal alternative is to

  167. need money bad

    bd65 wow look it is endurance

    bd65 is at be cheap

    bd65 anyone purchase is online

    bd65

  168. google online is sales

  169. where to buy viagra for cheap

  170. where can i be is tablet

  171. viagra online kaufende

  172. how com viagra cost so much

  173. price of viagra in cozumel

  174. cash wrap counter

    bd65 is medical stores delhi

    bd65 is at be cheap

    bd65 online legal is

    bd65

  175. rr payday advance

    bd65 cheap red is

    bd65 is 5mg daily use

    bd65 is 50 preis

    bd65

  176. online is preisvergleich

  177. reputable online viagra

  178. phone in order for viagra plus

  179. canada viagra canada cheap

  180. what is cash advance interest

    bd65 comprare is ato

    bd65 be australian is

    bd65 difference in is mg

    bd65

  181. click here viagra soft

  182. cash loans in cookeville tn

    bd65 is pricing at costco

    bd65 usefull link be is pills

    bd65 is frau online bestellen

    bd65

  183. what are some legitimate online payday loans

    bd65 wow look it is endurance

    bd65 liquid is 30mg

    bd65 be cheap is with amex

    bd65

  184. us or canada discount is

  185. viagra generico costo

  186. faxless bad credit payday loan online

    bd65 is 50mg cos

    bd65 achetez 80 mg is

    bd65 is atenolol

    bd65

  187. competitive loan rates

    bd65 rezeptfrei is preis

    bd65 original is commercial

    bd65 acheter is femm

    bd65

  188. emergency loan shsu

    bd65 isnde zero assoluto

    bd65 el is es mejor

    bd65 is online schnell

    bd65

  189. what is cash advance interest

    bd65 be is bali

    bd65 is farmacia svizzera

    bd65 the best site is in canada

    bd65

  190. viagra red bull juntos

  191. viagra purchase in uk

  192. payday loan in oregon city

    bd65 cheapest at is india

    bd65 tomar is mujer

    bd65 laws on is uk

    bd65

  193. online viagra france

  194. wirkstoff is beipackzettel

  195. mercury drug store viagra

  196. sample viagra coupons

  197. i want a loan

    bd65 soft is tabs from canada

    bd65 is 5mg order online

    bd65 is online effects

    bd65

  198. cod online viagra cz

  199. cheapest viagra 100mg tablets

  200. get generic viagra online

  201. achat viagra arnaque

  202. payday loans in sapulpa ok

    bd65 acquistare is forum

    bd65 look here is soft tablets

    bd65 only here is 100mg

    bd65

  203. expired viagra cialis levitr

  204. cash loans in cookeville tn

    bd65 compra is

    bd65 online at is 5 mg

    bd65 achat is 150 mg

    bd65

  205. personal loan maximum period

    bd65 at is and alcohol

    bd65 is at brand names

    bd65 generische is is

    bd65

  206. wirkstoff viagra beipackzettel

  207. installment loans how they work

    bd65 is doctors sacramento ca

    bd65 cheap is prices canadian

    bd65 anyone purchase is online

    bd65

  208. need money bad

    bd65 is varighet

    bd65 is en pastilla

    bd65 effet is verg

    bd65

  209. avis viagra cialis levitr

  210. is plus for discount

  211. West Houston HOU cash advance

    bd65 is 50mg cos

    bd65 comprar is por paypal

    bd65 try it order is cheap

    bd65

  212. generic suppliers buy viagra

  213. nea personal loan

    bd65 we like it is purchase

    bd65 we recommend natural is

    bd65 want order is online

    bd65

  214. kanada preiswerter viagra

  215. is frauen online kaufen

  216. West Houston HOU cash advance

    bd65 we like it is purchase

    bd65 is arizona

    bd65 being is costa rica

    bd65

  217. can heart patition take viagra

  218. waar kan ik viagra bestellen

  219. guaranteed loans ost

    bd65 best uk cheapest is 100mg

    bd65 is nez bouch

    bd65 generisch is online

    bd65

  220. watch viagra blue online

Leave a Reply